Feedback

[billy]

To some of our newer members, please read the rules on how to give feedback for each of our three critique forums. While you will get some leeway, it will be only a short period of grace. After said grace you will be excommunicated

[Brokenangel1960]

Do you need to give feedback in one of the critique forums before posting a poem or do you have to post once in each level? I dont feel qualified to give an in depth critique

[CRNDLSM]

Do you need to give feedback in one of the critique forums before posting a poem or do you have to post once in each level? I dont feel qualified to give an in depth critique

Before you post your own in a critique forum, post a critique of someone else's within that forum.  

A good guideline for intensive is to comment on each line, then a paragraph of the whole.  Although intensive can mean different things to different people, a good guide is to give what youd expect sort of.  For basic, pick something you like, something you don't like, a reason why for both and maybe a suggestion on how to improve it.  

Worst case the mods leave red letters or pause your posts, maybe it could be worse

[Brokenangel1960]

Do you need to give feedback in one of the critique forums before posting a poem or do you have to post once in each level? I dont feel qualified to give an in depth critique

Before you post your own in a critique forum, post a critique of someone else's within that forum.  

A good guideline for intensive is to comment on each line, then a paragraph of the whole.  Although intensive can mean different things to different people, a good guide is to give what youd expect sort of.  For basic, pick something you like, something you don't like, a reason why for both and maybe a suggestion on how to improve it.  

Worst case the mods leave red letters or pause your posts, maybe it could be worse

Thanks for clarifying