Stairy night

[wasellajam]

It's ok to say that a poem doesn't resonate with you, you can still give it a critique and even incorporate why it doesn't resonate with you as part of the critique, especially if you could give suggestions as to how to make it more engaging.

Got it!

You can also pick a poem you like and try to figure out what makes it appeal to you. A positive critique is fine if you can give details about what you like and why. Here's a thread with what to look for when you read.
Just a few points will make a critique.

https://www.pigpenpoetry.com/thread-25166.html