The PigPen's Resplendent Kaffeeklatsch

[milo]

 I remember Tom ragging on me for not posting a poem in intensive, my response being that a crit with just one point could be the vital. On the other end a critique that’s too intensive could cause someone to flee. Maybe tags in the thread title: Mild, intensive or 
any. ????

yah, maybe, but to what purpose.  I can't imagine someone requesting intensive being upset if they only received a minor bit of feedback

Maybe it's just me being me. If I can't wrap my head around the basic concept of a poem in intensive (Jove, Michael wtf?), or not as knowledgeable about poetic devices,  then I don't comment about the passages I can understand there. I always felt like less informed comments were more appropriate in the other workshops. Maybe it's just me.

I agree 100% which is why I think maybe we should consider just having a Poems for Feedback forum and a Poems not for Feedback forum

That way everyone can give feedback to their respective interest/ability

honestly, a lot of times I don't feel like giving feedback in intensive because I may not have that much I want to say