Critique is dead

[busker]

Or is it?
ChatGPT critics poetry better than most critiques unless you’re looking for someone to tear into you and call your work a PoS. ChatGPT can’t insult you as well as a flesh and blood human

I haven't tried chatGPT yet as I still like flesh and blood humans who I can argue with about inflections and other stuff, when I'm feeling like I want. I guess for me critiquing poetry and also getting critiques back is a great part of social interaction. I worry that AI will take that away.

Though when flesh and blood humans get a bit too arsey. I tend to go away and shout into the void about them being "stinky poo bums" who "wouldn't understand poetry if it came up to them and said 'ello I'm a nice sonnet. look at my fourteen lines of wonder'"

I also may need to go be in a corner and have some alone time until reality gets back to way it should be.

ChatGPT Pro gives better critique than most humans. The problem is that it's not very good at arguing, so you can ultimately get it to back down too easily.
So yes, flesh and blood humans still shine when it comes to holding their own.