06-18-2019, 10:41 PM
(06-16-2019, 05:05 PM)cloud Wrote: with god created intentThis is intriguing, and contains thought-provoking images (for example, roads losing parallel lines - are we talking perspective here, with vanishing points?)
the air lifted and grew thin,
roads lost parallel lines,
and the working class mustered:
clergymen, buskers and bakers,
clerks and townsmen,
all stood motionless
amidst the wake.
one man smirked, as if to give off
the whole charade.
In basic critique, although you've chosen not to use strict punctuation, etc., I'd suggest a hyphen to make "god-created," even though it would tend to lock out some readings or interpretations. I don't consider clergymen, generally, members of the working class - the group includes bishops, etc. - so perhaps "parsons" even though they may be a bit more educated than the average busker.
There are some good chops - "roads lost parallel lines" rolls off the tongue as well as being an arresting image.
I do question a couple of words - hope this is not excessive for Basic. One is "wake," which simultaneously suggests (to me) the wake of a ship - makes sense in context - and the traditional liquid-fueled funereal sendoff. Which may just be a wrong idea on my part, but it doesn't fit well with the very sober image of mustered and motionless bystanders.
The other is "off" (in "as if to give off/the whole charade" at the end). I get the meaning from context - as we would say in the US, to give away a secret with an overtone of doing it unintentionally or disobediently. In US parlance, "give off" connotes an emanation as in "give off light" or "give off" a bad smell. So I'd replace "off" with "away" there, but only if that means the same thing on both sides of the pond.
I liked it, it's mysterious and visual, showing instead of telling.
Non-practicing atheist


