12-23-2017, 02:43 PM
Hi Lizzie,
Here are some comments for you.
Best,
Todd
Here are some comments for you.
(12-09-2017, 04:14 AM)Lizzie Wrote: Pleading With an Ibid's HemI hope the comments will be helpful.
The dream began as they often do:
familiar dread, unfamiliar place—--This opening is slightly flat. If the speaker is going to be a sort of modern Casandra then starting at something more meaningful would help. I'm not a real fan of familiar/unfamiliar only because it's predictable.
children with the names I gave them,
ages flouting linear time.
Men stood in rows like solemn corn—--I would probably start here. This is an interesting, vibrant image. It even has a hint of danger (waiting to be reaped). I could be missing something in the sequencing but I think the children could be reinserted later.
a marching band missing a routine and music—
with Paul Ryan's slicked black All-American hair,
matching navy blue fitted suits,
and placid eyes that followed--really like the break on followed. I think the Paul Ryan comparison lines are done well.
the golden bullet gleaming overhead.--slightly reminds me of the Kennedy assassination--though I'm taking this more as a portent of coming wrath and judgment.
Their eyes were drawn in time--don't really like the repetition of eyes or time here. (something simpler and less repetitious. Maybe, "they tracked its line...sky")
along its line through the sky,
tuning to the mastery of a new conductor,--I keep wanting to replace tuning with "and tuned"
mouths slung open the way they slack
when the mind abandons consciousness.--condense these two lines perhaps.
There was no warning but mine,--Here is Casandra
or sign from Yahweh—
no rainbow or prepared ark.--Sequence the ark should precede the rainbow
They never looked down or to the side,--This is probably meant to also explain a rigid mindset.
so they didn't see us wash away.--It's interesting (though not surprising with the political reference) that the judgment falls on the "us" not the "them". It's a good literary allusion to Noah--which in itself is a nod to end times statements.
Best,
Todd
The secret of poetry is cruelty.--Jon Anderson
