08-15-2017, 01:44 PM
(08-15-2017, 12:21 PM)Tiger the Lion Wrote: Hello Janine. A few comments for you...
(08-15-2017, 10:57 AM)nibbed Wrote: True Beauty - I don't think the title does much for the piece. It could introduce almost anything.Thanks for the read. I enjoyed it even if the comments suggest otherwise.
He sends comfort
in lonely tribulation,
creating distraction: I'm having a hard time reconciling comfort and tribulation. They are almost complete opposites - though I realize this was partly intentional, it is jarring nonetheless. (after rereading I think switching L1 and L2 would make it more clear - as is the word "in" has an ambiguous use. yes, thank you. I see where that would really work well and convey what I meant.
His firmaments
daub in powerful billows,
forming softened This may read more smoothly as "soft, whimsical..." - might just be my ear
whimsy caricatures;
His handiwork
displays a mystery
found only in feathers & frond. Assuming the N is talking about a diety of some kind, "only" feels contradictory. Upon reading it just now
I don't know why only is in there...must have been a remnant from one of my drafts! Thanks for pointing that out! Directing windy offerings Apologies, but "windy offerings" immediately made me think of farts. - Aside from that, I enjoyed this strophe the most. hahahaha! I actually wondered that,too, but thought I was being goofy
of cornered angels
teasing in hints
of sweetened honeysuckle
& wild carrots
crocheted in blooms of white,
He soothes
tormented ears
with the auditions may not need "the" here k
of sparrows,
crickets & frogs;
boasting purest galleries
in precious, brilliant, song. "precious" and "brilliant" seem rather generic adjectives for a last line. If I'm wrong I would still strike the comma after brilliant. Good point. It's hard being descriptive of things concerning my God, I mean, His greatness and all the stuff He is. There's not a word in any dictionary that can quite convey how I feel about Him or His attributes. I think there will be a different language of praise in heaven, unimaginable, better words because great, marvelous, wonderful, just don't seem good enough! He's even more!
Paul
thanks Tiger the lion! Your critique was wonderful
and quite helpful to me! I wish I could critique as
wonderfully and as thoroughly as you!
nibbed
there's always a better reason to love


