12-14-2016, 02:06 AM
(12-14-2016, 01:35 AM)dukealien Wrote: @RiverNotch - Your critique is particularly valued, though the edit complies with its recommendations the least. They lead in the direction of a better poem, but I'm caught up in the story and how I set about telling it. If I were a better poet, I could do both!
edit2;
Armistice Wind
On Friday last, an hour before
the sun reached its meridian The context above makes me appreciate this a good deal more. "the sun reached its meridian" still reads particularly belabored, but not too bad, and it's in the service of a meter that is justified. The softness of the whole thing, enhanced by the meter, is a thing I neglected to mention, though I definitely felt it....
I listened indoors for the crash
of guns.
Police shoot volleys on this day
each year in my town’s graveyard, blanks
to symbolize an armistice - ....just as I felt what the speaker meant in separating armistice from peace, beyond any semantic tensions or specific references. I guess I'm now fine with the piece not treating that bit of history with as much care.
not peace.
Little heard, just acorns falling
rattled like spent bullets on
hunched helmets as they struck my roof
and rolled. The image is there, just as it was before, but the fragmentary nature of the stanza still bothers, and "like spent bullets on / hunched helmets" still reads misplaced.
An east wind stirred dead leaves and limbs
to rustle, flutter, softly thunder,
warning ghost of distant drumfire
waking. But the removal of "between" here is an improvement, and "warning ghost of distant drumfire" remains well appreciated.
Then louder, rushing past, that gale
blew shrill, demanding pan-pipe notes -
trench-whistles calling men to rise
and fall.
So Friday last I never heard
those guns proclaiming armistice:
wind must have carried their reports
away.
Lovelier, though, as noted, the third still bothers, and the first being a bit too much is still noticeable. The third really needs some restructuring -- I would suggest something more radical, like smushing 1 and 3 together, but I realize that would be too much for this piece.

