04-03-2015, 12:34 AM
(04-01-2015, 05:22 AM)christophx Wrote:thank you for taking the time to read and critique, it is much appreciated.(03-30-2015, 02:05 PM)cjchaffin Wrote: SavannahI like it a lot. Inspiring to me,especially
Your sweet magnolia scent
mingles with the heat of my skin, Really strong start, simply a pleasure to read
wet hands clutching crushed petals. The phrase "wet hands" seems out of place to me here, although I understand what you're saying clearly.
I offer them to the sea I feel that if you reword this (remove "offer them") there is more room for an image that really allows you to express your ideas effectively
and lie down in the cool shallows.
Stretched out on Georgia sands
where clay meets saltwater,
I finally whisper your name. Really pleasing, gentle
(04-02-2015, 05:43 PM)A.H.Lavender Wrote:thank you for your candor, you raise some valid questions that i will take into consideration. i take nothing personally. i'm here to improve, otherwise what is the point of posting in this forum.(03-30-2015, 02:05 PM)cjchaffin Wrote: SavannahDue to its theme, I wanted to like this poem, but the writing is a let-down for me. A re-write, with additional and better lines, and more interesting word choices,
Your sweet magnolia scent
mingles with the heat of my skin,
wet hands clutching crushed petals. --------Whose hands? Yours? I know what you're attempting to convey, but the wording fails.
I offer them to the sea --------where'd the sea pop up from? First strophe doesn't lead to the shore; you could just as well have been gardening.
and lie down in the cool shallows. -------"lie down" can be improved upon.
Stretched out on Georgia sands---------"Stretched out"--even poorer than "lie down."
where clay meets saltwater,---------clay? nah. An unpoetic line.
I finally whisper your name. ----------Savannah? We already knew that from the title. Sorry, but it's a weak ending.
is my suggestion. Offered to help improve your writing skills. Understand that you are not your poem--don't take it personally.


