10-23-2014, 05:17 AM
Well... you asked:
Lots of crits, but for a first poem this is quite good. (My first poem, btw, was more than 100 times worse.)
lips grow hard and dry
do lips grow hard? cracked and dry maybe /but then it's cliché
maybe find some other way to describe or leave out this line
tongue lay still with stiffness in mouth awkward
toes turned in permanence and fingers tangled
'toes turned in' or 'toes turned in in permanence' ? confusing as don't
know what 'in' goes with / toes curled? bent?
hair brittle and without shine pare down
warmth departs and feeling with it
skin flakes away like cigarette-stained wall paper good image though
logically cigarette stains don't make wallpaper flake
in photographs of me I cannot breathe use comma after 'me' or make two lines
in photographs I cannot speak maybe same as above, though it does work
whiteness of teeth from years and use darkened awkward, do you mean that
white teeth have been darkened from years 'of' use or years 'and' use? /
either way it's cliché so figure out some other 'teeth' image
like missing bricks and falling bridges good idea but mouths sometimes
have dental bridges so it reads like a pun and that's not in keeping with
the attitude of the poem
distant memory of mothers joy should be "mother's" / "mother's joy" is trite
of white skin and dewy eyes dewy eyes cliché
tiny hands and yellow curls use synonym of 'tiny'
lungs shining like pink birthday balloons is 'birthday' necessary?
heart tapping like rain on aluminum do hearts tap?
but puckered creases of time cross the face do creases pucker? /
having 'time' directly proceed 'cross' makes it sound like the creases are moving as we are reading it
and spots of life lay on hands and arms i know what 'spots of life' are (have some myself) but it sounds more awkward than poetic
sunken eyes sit by hanging skin 'sunken eyes' is cliché but not that bad / but eyes sitting 'by' skin is a bit cartoonish
like tire grooves worn into over-driven roads maybe something other than 'over-driven'
this last stanza is corny, preachy, needs rewrite or elimination
but I did like the images in certain lines / if you rewrite use these /
just describe the images, don't give instructions, make decrees
let us begin again cliché
may sweat and spit join rain in clouds awkward but love connecting sweat, spit, and rain
buried body unite with mud cliché do like 'body' connected to 'mud' work with that
so make it true cliché
the endlessness cliché
hope of renewal cliché
cycle of flesh cliché
Lots of crits, but for a first poem this is quite good. (My first poem, btw, was more than 100 times worse.)
lips grow hard and dry
do lips grow hard? cracked and dry maybe /but then it's cliché
maybe find some other way to describe or leave out this line
tongue lay still with stiffness in mouth awkward
toes turned in permanence and fingers tangled
'toes turned in' or 'toes turned in in permanence' ? confusing as don't
know what 'in' goes with / toes curled? bent?
hair brittle and without shine pare down
warmth departs and feeling with it
skin flakes away like cigarette-stained wall paper good image though
logically cigarette stains don't make wallpaper flake
in photographs of me I cannot breathe use comma after 'me' or make two lines
in photographs I cannot speak maybe same as above, though it does work
whiteness of teeth from years and use darkened awkward, do you mean that
white teeth have been darkened from years 'of' use or years 'and' use? /
either way it's cliché so figure out some other 'teeth' image
like missing bricks and falling bridges good idea but mouths sometimes
have dental bridges so it reads like a pun and that's not in keeping with
the attitude of the poem
distant memory of mothers joy should be "mother's" / "mother's joy" is trite
of white skin and dewy eyes dewy eyes cliché
tiny hands and yellow curls use synonym of 'tiny'
lungs shining like pink birthday balloons is 'birthday' necessary?
heart tapping like rain on aluminum do hearts tap?
but puckered creases of time cross the face do creases pucker? /
having 'time' directly proceed 'cross' makes it sound like the creases are moving as we are reading it
and spots of life lay on hands and arms i know what 'spots of life' are (have some myself) but it sounds more awkward than poetic
sunken eyes sit by hanging skin 'sunken eyes' is cliché but not that bad / but eyes sitting 'by' skin is a bit cartoonish
like tire grooves worn into over-driven roads maybe something other than 'over-driven'
this last stanza is corny, preachy, needs rewrite or elimination
but I did like the images in certain lines / if you rewrite use these /
just describe the images, don't give instructions, make decrees
let us begin again cliché
may sweat and spit join rain in clouds awkward but love connecting sweat, spit, and rain
buried body unite with mud cliché do like 'body' connected to 'mud' work with that
so make it true cliché
the endlessness cliché
hope of renewal cliché
cycle of flesh cliché
a brightly colored fungus that grows in bark inclusions

