An Epic of Regret
#5
Phew! Well that took me awhile. I understand the overall theme of your poem. I get that it's about a prince who got revenge but died with regret. At least, that's what I got from it. My comments are in bold. There is a lot unclear to me in this poem. You'll see what I mean as you read my comments.

(02-06-2014, 01:23 PM)DominoMan Wrote:  "It is not unlike the days of mice and men [If this idea flows to the next line, then you should not end it with a period.]
When ancient stories were written on barley, [No comma needed.]
by the heave of a fountain pen.

Two, ten men armies they held the rubble [I don't think a comma should got after "Two." Instead, put a comma after "Two ten men armies." It should read as such, "Two ten men armies, they held the rubble."]
For the glory of their kings.
When a queen she held a little prince, [Eliminate "when" from here. I think it would flow better without it.]
and a little box seemed to sing. [I'm curious about this singing box. Where is it?]

The boy he grew and when he did, [Eliminate the first "he." It disrupts the flow of the line.]
his mind began to ponder.
The story starts there; be it wrong or fair, [What do you mean by "be it wrong or fair?"]
For a pen should not far wander.[What pen? How does this line relate to the previous line? I don't see the connection with the rest of the idea in this stanza.]


He saw a face, the face of a young fair lass
With childish hands that held a comb, [No comma needed.]
Over locks that were gold as brass.

A minute later, the scene it changed [How does the prince go from seeing a girl to seeing war? You lost me a bit here. Also, just eliminate the first line, "A minute later, the scene it changed." Just go into the scene. We'll know it changed when we read it. Get what I mean?]
And war began to spread.
Betrayal came fast and the king he fell; [Get rid of "he." ELIMINATE THAT SEMICOLON! None of the semicolon rules apply to this. ]
Through lies, that he was fed.

No more did he, the prince no more,[This worded weirdly. Make more concise.]
Think of food or gold.
Revenge was near, he did not fear
For life, his will was told. [What do you mean by "his will was told"?]

Few years passed till he came of age to lead
Mighty men, who drank down blood [No comma in that line. Whose blood did they drink? The gods' blood?]
when gods in battles, bleed. [No comma.]

Ten days raged; on red stained soil, [Get rid of that semicolon and comma.]
the battle for a throne,
but the boy he knew, the field he toiled, [Eliminate that first "he."]
was for anger he felt alone.

Starved by hate and drenched in grief,
The boy he won the hand. [Get rid of that "he." Too many extra "he's" in this poem.]
But the price of war was far too great,
and he fell on the line of sand. [I'm having trouble picturing what you mean by "line of sand." Was he on a shoreline?]

It is not unlike the days of mice and men.
When an ancient story was spoken for glory
Too great to be written by pen.

Two, thousand men armies; one held the rubble, [Same as earlier on. You don't need that first comma after "two."]
In the name of it's late king.[If the idea in this line continues to the next, you don't need to end it with a period.]
Whose queen she held a little prince,
while a little box, it did sing. [Reword this. What box? Same box as earlier? Is this a musical box? Who does it belong to?]

The boy he grew and he did ponder
The last sight of dark revenge. [Did he get revenge? Revenge for whom? This idea is unclear to me.]
The story ends here, for his was near.
He thought at his final hour. [Was his fate the same as the previous prince? I'm confused as to what is going on in this stanza.]


He remembered her face, the face of a young fair lass
With childish hands that held a comb,
Over locks that were gold as brass." [Who is this girl? Is she the same one from before? What is her connection to the story? Why do the princes keep seeing her?]

Well Im kind of new to poetry so any pointers will be happily accepted. Especially when it comes to punctuations. Thanks for reading.
Reply


Messages In This Thread
An Epic of Regret - by DominoMan - 02-06-2014, 01:23 PM
RE: An Epic of Regret - by Arachnid_Poet - 02-06-2014, 03:09 PM
RE: An Epic of Regret - by DominoMan - 02-06-2014, 03:44 PM
RE: An Epic of Regret - by Arachnid_Poet - 02-06-2014, 04:02 PM
RE: An Epic of Regret - by ralex003 - 02-07-2014, 01:07 PM
RE: An Epic of Regret - by Lisa - 02-07-2014, 08:12 PM



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!