crap feedback

[R.C. KITCHENS]

Why can't we have a critique critique forum?

Let people post their critique and have it rated by the poetry mods-- no repercussions, just for edu-fun-acation?

I would love to do something along these lines. As a note, some of the other sites have, in addition to a spotlighting the "poems" section like we have, a spotlighting the critiques section, where particularly good critique is called out, so others can see, aspire, learn, etc.

I've seen that too. I think the vanity poetry.com keeps count of the critiques you have given. That might be a useful tool.