Salt Water
#3
Hi HHB,

Welcome to the site! Here are some comments for you:

I like you're title and first line. It like that you allude to sadness without blatantly beating us over the head. You make stylistic choices CAPs at the beginning of the line and no end punctuation--not an issue. As you don't enjamb the lines, I didn't find it confusing.

(05-24-2013, 06:04 AM)HelenaHandbasket Wrote:  Your bones are filled with salt water
Doldrums beat in your hulls--Nice play on an internal roiling sea of misery. I like the imagery a great deal. It gets the poem off to a good start
Your wood is bleached, twisted in cliffs--If there was a way you could minimize the your's in this piece, it might be tighter
Time wounds your heals--Nice inversion of the expected cliche. You do that a lot, and I like it. You expect depressed poem cliches and what you get is something slightly at a slant. The slant makes for a fun read
Echoes are hollow reminders that no one thinks the way you do--beautiful line. Evocative idea. It gives the sense that we may all look alike, but we are aliens on the inside
Rain drops spring like dancers--again great image. Nice play on spring with rain. Since you're switching the imagery up, this may be a good line to start a new strophe on.
Nose burns like a house fire
Bread crumbs kill ducks and wad up in your throat--end punctuation would allow you to break the line after ducks, as it stands you've made the right decision keeping the line intact.
So you hold her at arm’s length.--given the last line I think you can lose the you. This lines let's us know what the issue is. I can see why you've kept this as one strophe given the content so I may rescind my earlier break idea, but it still may have merit. Play around with maybe, if you agree

If you can see her feet, maybe this one will stay--quirky but interesting. An expectation of her running away
If you have to count on your toes
How many of her roots have laced through you--I love the roots laced phrasing and the concept. These two lines feel like they have an odd transition between them though
Maybe that means that this one will stay--Maybe a simpler refrain repeating the last cutting "that means"
At night she’ll shake like an alarm
Her eyes will flash in your darkness like a lighthouse--I'm not a fan of "in your darkness" though I like the imagery you're going with
Let your roots find her’s--find feels wrong. A better more evocative substitute
And let her light unhinge your bones--In my opinion this should be your last line. It has better symmetry
And you can beat against the sea together--cut "you can"
Instead of letting it beat inside you--Too telling, I'd cut it
Just some thoughts. I very much enjoyed the read.

Best,

Todd
The secret of poetry is cruelty.--Jon Anderson
Reply


Messages In This Thread
Salt Water - by HelenaHandbasket - 05-24-2013, 06:04 AM
RE: Salt Water - by rowens - 05-24-2013, 06:16 AM
RE: Salt Water - by Todd - 05-24-2013, 10:38 AM
RE: Salt Water - by billy - 05-24-2013, 12:29 PM
RE: Salt Water - by milo - 05-24-2013, 12:52 PM



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)
Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!