Difference between poetry and prose?

[billy]

I'm inclined to agree with Rose (and therefore Rowens) here, about the purpose or deliberate intent when the piece was originally penned /created.
That, to some extent the author has to have a greater say than the individual "critique" reguardless of whether the item is a good example or follows the rules. Having said that we then get back to the emperor's new clothes syndrome and at some point common consent and common sense should be allowed to weigh in and make the call over if it is a shovel or a spade.

sorry hit wrong button this comment is in reply to Rose on P3!

You guys carry, on I'll catch up in a mo...turn around for half a day to look at something else and everyone's buggered off without you.